Don't want to trade it yourself?
Our desk runs DEX portfolios on profit share.
Add to Google Preferred Sources
A price comparison by trader Denis Liu challenges the narrative that altcoins are broadly outperforming Bitcoin. By examining prices on August 22 and September 9, when Bitcoin traded near $78,300 on both dates, Liu found that most large altcoins barely moved—Ethereum fell 1%, XRP dropped 2%, and Cardano declined 3%—while only Solana, BNB, and Chainlink posted meaningful gains of 10%, 9%, and 5% respectively. Liu argues these tokens follow Bitcoin’s lead rather than decouple from it. The finding contrasts with analyst Matthew Hyland’s view that over 100 altcoins are outperforming across multiple timeframes, supported by bullish macro indicators and record altcoin futures open interest. The data suggests current altcoin strength is concentrated in a few names rather than spread across the broader market.
Key Elements
The widely circulated claim that altcoins are broadly outperforming Bitcoin is facing fresh scrutiny after a simple price comparison revealed that most large-cap alternatives barely budged during a period when the flagship cryptocurrency was essentially flat.
Denis Liu, a trader known as VirtualBacon on X, compared altcoin prices on August 22 and September 9—two dates when Bitcoin was trading at nearly identical levels. The benchmark cryptocurrency sat at $78,313 on the first date and $78,440 on the second, a difference of less than 0.2% over the 17-day stretch.
Against that baseline, the results were sobering for altcoin bulls. Ethereum fell 1%, XRP dropped 2%, Dogecoin declined 2%, Tron lost 1%, and Cardano was down 3%. Avalanche was the lone gainer among the larger names, rising 2%.
The data showed that six of the nine largest altcoins remained within a few percentage points of their August 22 levels. The pattern suggests these tokens move higher when Bitcoin rallies but surrender much of those gains when the leading cryptocurrency stalls
“A coin that only moves louder than Bitcoin is still following Bitcoin,” Liu wrote in his September 9 post.
The comparison did reveal notable exceptions. Solana climbed 10% over the period, BNB advanced 9%, and Chainlink gained 5%. However, Liu argued that capturing those moves required owning the assets before their narratives became widely discussed across social media and trading communities. By the time a story spreads, much of the price appreciation may have already occurred.
“I’m sitting in Bitcoin and waiting,” he wrote. “Not because altcoins are finished, I do not think that at all. It is because ‘altcoins are outperforming’ turned out to mean two or three of them did.”
His stance does not dismiss the possibility of an altcoin rally outright. Rather, it pushes back against extrapolating the performance of a handful of strong movers to the entire sector.
The Bullish Counterargument
A competing narrative continues to circulate, most prominently from analyst Matthew Hyland, who contends that more than 100 top altcoins are outperforming Bitcoin across multiple timeframes. The analyst first made the case in July, arguing that macro-risk indicators have turned bullish for the first time since the 2016-2017 and 2020-2021 market cycles.
Hyland has pointed to several broad altcoin gauges—including Total 2, Total 3, and OTHERS—breaking multi-year downtrends. He has also highlighted a notable development in derivatives markets: altcoin perpetual futures open interest overtook Bitcoin’s for the first time since December 2024, which he interprets as positioning for what could be the largest altcoin bull run on record.
The two perspectives address fundamentally different questions. Hyland is focused on a potential future expansion of altcoin strength, while Liu’s price check measures what has actually happened over a specific recent window. During a flat two-and-a-half-week period for Bitcoin, most of the market’s biggest altcoins barely moved.
What the Data Actually Shows
The performance divergence among major altcoins during Bitcoin’s flat stretch highlights the uneven nature of the current market. While a select group posted meaningful gains, the broader large-cap cohort largely tracked Bitcoin’s sideways action.
The table below summarizes the price changes for major altcoins between August 22 and September 9, when Bitcoin was nearly unchanged:
| Cryptocurrency | Change |
|---|---|
| Solana | +10% |
| BNB | +9% |
| Chainlink | +5% |
| Avalanche | +2% |
| Ethereum | -1% |
| Tron | -1% |
| XRP | -2% |
| Dogecoin | -2% |
| Cardano | -3% |
Note: Figures reflect price changes between August 22 and September 9, 2026, a period when Bitcoin traded at approximately $78,300 to $78,440 on both dates.
For investors and traders, the key question going forward is whether the outperformance seen in Solana, BNB, and Chainlink can broaden across the altcoin universe—or whether the current environment remains one where only a handful of names generate meaningful alpha while the rest of the market simply tracks Bitcoin with higher volatility.
The divergence underscores a practical challenge for market participants: identifying which narratives will gain traction before they become consensus views. As Liu’s comparison illustrates, waiting for confirmation that an altcoin story has spread often means entering positions after the most significant price moves have already played out.
For now, the data suggests that “altcoins are beating Bitcoin” is less a market-wide phenomenon than a description of a select group of outperformers. Whether that narrow leadership expands will determine whether the bullish calls from analysts like Hyland materialize into a broader rally—or whether Bitcoin’s gravitational pull continues to anchor the market.
Once added, BigGo Finance appears first in Google Search Top Stories, so you get the broadest, most up-to-the-minute, and most comprehensive global financial news first.
Source: finance.biggo.com